How AI is fueling an existential crisis in education

AI Summary3 min read

TL;DR

Generative AI is causing deep existential crises in education, with teachers questioning the purpose of their roles as AI handles tasks like course creation and grading. While some find AI helpful, most face challenges that go beyond cheating to the core philosophy of education.

Here on Decoder, we’ve talked a lot about generative AI, which is a very big idea that is causing quite a few problems. One thing we keep hearing about over and over again is that generative AI is causing a lot of problems in schools.

A lot of people out there, including many of the listeners of this show who email us, are worried about the obvious problem: students using ChatGPT to cheat on assignments — and yes, some students definitely do.

Verge subscribers, don’t forget you get exclusive access to ad-free Decoder wherever you get your podcasts. Head here. Not a subscriber? You can sign up here.

But when our team poked at the story, we found that the issues with AI in education go a lot deeper, to the very philosophy of education itself.

The Decoder team talked to a lot of teachers — you’ll be hearing many of their voices throughout this episode — and we kept hearing one common theme from many of them: What are we even doing here?

As one instructional designer you’ll hear says, “If this technology becomes more ubiquitous, we’ll have courses created by AI, graded by AI, with submissions from students absolutely generated by AI. So it begs the question: What are we even doing here in higher ed?”

Every teacher is having a different experience with AI in the classroom, and with their students, but the common thread is that a lot of those experiences feel bad. A few teachers who talked to us find tools like ChatGPT are helping their workflow, but a definite majority is facing those deep existential questions.

Luckily, there are people whose job it is to be experts in education and educational technology, to research what’s going on in a more detailed way. So I sat down with Dr. Adam Dubé, from McGill University, to talk about how generative AI is fitting into education right now and where all of this might be going in the future.

If you’d like to read more about what we discussed in this episode, check out these links:

A majority of high school students use gen AI for schoolwork | College Board
About a quarter of teens have used ChatGPT for schoolwork | Pew Research
Your brain on ChatGPT | MIT Media Lab
My students think it’s fine to cheat with AI. Maybe they’re on to something. | Vox
How children understand and learn from conversational AI | McGill University
File not Found | The Verge

_{Questions or comments about this episode? Hit us up at [email protected]. We really do read every email!}